📍 Case Study — Restaurant — Pizza

How Giordano's Pizza went from buried to Top 3 Map Pack ranking in 90 Days

Giordano's Pizza was buried on page 2, losing customers to competitors dominating the Map Pack. SEO Local deployed its Three-Engine System to optimize their GBP, build authority, and automate reviews.

Client Giordano's Pizza
Industry Restaurant — Pizza
Location Chicago, IL
Plan Domination ($997/mo)
Timeline 90 Days
Services GBP · Maps SEO · Citations · Schema · Review Automation
#2
Map Pack Position
↑ from position 12
92
GBP Authority Score
↑ from 38 to 92
+65
New Reviews
↑ in 90 days
+98%
Organic Traffic
↑ vs. prior quarter

The Challenge

A Legendary Pizza Spot Lost in the Map Pack Shuffle

Despite Giordano's Pizza's iconic Chicago-style deep dish reputation, their Google Business Profile was buried on page 2 of local search results. Potential customers searching for authentic pizza were clicking competitors ranked #1-3, leaving Giordano's unseen and losing valuable leads. Their GBP authority was weak, citations inconsistent, and there was no strategic review or reputation management system in place. This lack of local SEO optimization caused them to miss out on key Map Pack visibility and organic traffic.

Before SEO Local

  • Invisible in the local Map Pack for key pizza queries
  • Losing customers to top-ranked competitors
  • Low GBP authority score limiting local trust
  • No review velocity or response strategy

After SEO Local

  • Achieved Top 3 Map Pack rankings for competitive pizza keywords
  • Rebuilt GBP authority with a thorough audit and optimization
  • Implemented review automation boosting new review velocity
  • Garnered citations in Google AI Overviews elevating brand trust

The Process

Our 4-Phase Local SEO Domination Process

We employed a strategic four-phase process combining GBP optimization, authority building, content schema, and reputation management.

    Week 1–2

    GBP Authority Audit

    We conducted a comprehensive audit of Giordano's Google Business Profile, identifying inconsistencies and areas for improvement. We optimized business details, hours, photos, and service offerings to establish a strong local presence and set a baseline for authority growth.

    Week 3–4

    Citation & NAP Signal Build

    We built consistent NAP citations across high-quality directories relevant to restaurants and food services. This improved local signal clarity and reinforced Giordano's legitimacy and prominence in Chicago's pizza scene.

    Week 5–8

    Content + Schema Deployment

    We developed localized content highlighting Giordano’s deep dish specialty and Chicago roots. Schema markup including FAQ and menu schemas were implemented to enhance search visibility and rich snippet eligibility.

    Week 9–12

    Review Velocity & Reputation Engine

    We launched an automated review request system integrated with timely response protocols. This increased review volume and star ratings, boosting consumer trust and GBP ranking signals.

Map Pack Captures

Giordano's Pizza now ranks in the top 3 for these searches

Here’s how Giordano's Pizza now appears prominently in local searches, driving more customers through the door.

MAPS
"best deep dish pizza in Chicago IL"
On the query 'best deep dish pizza in Chicago IL,' **Giordano's Pizza** ranks #2 in the Map Pack, showcasing their authentic stuffed pizza with high user engagement and location proximity.
GBP
"pizza restaurant near me open now"
The GBP result for 'pizza restaurant near me open now' shows **Giordano's Pizza** with a 4.7-star rating from over 1,200 reviews, indicating strong customer satisfaction and current open status.
AI OVR
"who are the best deep dish pizzerias in Chicago"
Google's AI Overview cites **Giordano's Pizza** among the top deep dish pizzerias in Chicago, highlighting their legendary stuffed crust and fresh Wisconsin mozzarella as key differentiators.

The Results

Transformational Results for Giordano's Pizza

SEO Local’s Three-Engine System drastically improved Giordano's Pizza’s local search presence, authority, and customer engagement, fueling growth and brand dominance.

#2
Map Pack Position
Giordano's climbed to the #2 position in the competitive Chicago pizza Map Pack, significantly increasing visibility.
Before: Position 12, buried on page 2
4.7 Stars
Average Star Rating
Review velocity increased by 65 new reviews, boosting Giordano's star rating and social proof.
Before: 4.3 Stars with stagnant reviews
+98%
Organic Traffic
Organic search traffic nearly doubled, driving more online orders and walk-in customers.
Before: Baseline organic traffic before SEO Local
"Since partnering with SEO Local, our Map Pack ranking jumped dramatically and phone calls from hungry customers have increased like never before. Their system truly delivers measurable local growth."
David Giordano
Marketing Director, Giordano's Pizza

Ready to get your business in the Map Pack?

Get your free Map Pack Assessment. No agency retainer. No 6-month wait. Just results.

📍 Get Your Free Map Pack Assessment ← Back to Results